← Back to Screener
ScreenerNewsCompareWatchlist
VCP ScannerFree US Stock Screener & Financial AnalysisFree US Stock Screener
ScreenerThemesNewsCompareWatchlist
AnalyzeValuationTotal ReturnDCA CalculatorInsider Activity

SAFT logoSafety Insurance Group, Inc.(SAFT)Earnings, Financials & Key Ratios

SAFT•NASDAQ•Insurance & Managed Care
$74.30
$1.09B mkt cap·11.1× P/E·Price updated May 6, 2026
SectorFinancial ServicesIndustryProperty & Casualty InsuranceSub-IndustryPersonal auto and homeowners insurers
AboutSafety Insurance Group, Inc. provides private passenger and commercial automobile, and homeowner insurance in the United States. The company's private passenger automobile policies offer coverage for bodily injury and property damage to others, no-fault personal injury coverage for the insured/insured's car occupants, and physical damage coverage for an insured's own vehicle for collision or other perils. It also provides commercial automobile policies that offer insurance for commercial vehicles used for business purposes, including private passenger-type vehicles, trucks, tractors and trailers, insure individual vehicles, and commercial fleets; and homeowners policies, which provide coverage for homes, condominiums, and apartments for losses to a dwelling and its contents from various perils, and coverage for liability to others arising from ownership or occupancy. In addition, the company offers business owners policies that cover apartments and residential condominiums, restaurants, office condominiums, processing and services businesses, special trade contractors, and wholesalers. Further, it provides personal umbrella policies, which provide personal excess liability coverage over and above the limits of individual automobile, watercraft, and homeowner's insurance policies; and commercial umbrella and business owner policies, as well as underwrites dwelling fire insurance for non-owner-occupied residences. Additionally, the company offers inland marine coverage for homeowners and business owner policies, and watercraft coverage for small and medium sized pleasure crafts. It distributes its products through independent agents. The company was formerly known as Safety Holdings Inc and changed its name to Safety Insurance Group, Inc. in April 2002. Safety Insurance Group, Inc. was founded in 1979 and is headquartered in Boston, Massachusetts.Show more
  • Revenue$1.25B+13.0%
  • Combined Ratio89.9%-2.2%
  • Net Income$99M+40.3%
  • Return on Equity11.54%+33.1%
  • Medical Cost Ratio63.57%-1.6%
  • Operating Margin10.1%+24.7%
  • Net Margin7.91%+24.2%
  • ROA4.19%+29.2%
  • Equity / Assets36.11%-1.1%
  • Book Value per Share60.52+7.5%
  • Tangible BV/Share58.90+7.9%
  • Debt/Equity0.07+25.6%
Technical→

SAFT Key Insights

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) fundamental analysis — strengths, weaknesses & financial health based on data analysis

✓Strengths

  • ✓Company is almost debt free
  • ✓Profitable underwriting: 89.9% combined ratio
  • ✓Strong Piotroski F-Score: 7/9
  • ✓Healthy dividend yield of 4.9%
  • ✓Trading at only 1.2x book value

✗Weaknesses

No significant weaknesses identified

* These insights are generated automatically based on available financial data. Please conduct your own research before making investment decisions.

SAFT Price & Volume

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) stock price & volume — 10-year historical chart

Loading chart...

SAFT Growth Metrics

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) revenue, earnings & EPS growth — 3, 5 & 10-year CAGR

Revenue CAGR

10 Years4.55%
5 Years8.33%
3 Years16.9%
TTM13.01%

Profit CAGR

10 Years-
5 Years-6.41%
3 Years28.7%
TTM40.32%

EPS CAGR

10 Years-
5 Years-6.1%
3 Years28.6%
TTM40.46%

Return on Capital

10 Years5.51%
5 Years4.45%
3 Years3.63%
Last Year5.38%

SAFT Recent Earnings

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) EPS & revenue vs analyst estimates — last 4 quarters

Full history →
●Beat EPS 3/12 qtrs (25%)●Beat Revenue 0/12 qtrs (0%)
Q1 2026Latest
Feb 25, 2026
EPS
$1.51
Est $1.28
+18.0%
Revenue
$300M
Est $315M
-5.0%
Q4 2025
Nov 3, 2025
EPS
$1.48
Est $1.80
-17.8%
Revenue
$323M
Q3 2025
Aug 6, 2025
EPS
$1.45
Est $1.60
-9.4%
Revenue
$316M
Q2 2025
May 7, 2025
EPS
$1.28
Est $1.25
+2.4%
Revenue
$301M
QuarterDateEPS (Act vs Est)Revenue (Act vs Est)
Q1 2026LatestFeb 25, 2026
$1.51vs $1.28+18.0%
$300Mvs $315M-5.0%
Q4 2025Nov 3, 2025
$1.48vs $1.80-17.8%
$323M
Q3 2025Aug 6, 2025
$1.45vs $1.60-9.4%
$316M
Q2 2025May 7, 2025
$1.28vs $1.25+2.4%
$301M
Based on last 12 quarters of dataView full earnings history →

SAFT Peer Comparison

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) competitors in Personal auto and homeowners insurers — business model, growth, and fundamentals comparison

Select Columns
Stock Universe
Valuation
Growth
Profitability
Financial Health
Dividends & Buybacks
Price Performance
Technical
Fundamentals ($)
Sector-Specific
CompanyMarket CapStock PriceP/E Ratio (TTM)Revenue Growth 1YNet MarginReturn on Equity (ROE)FCF YieldDebt / Equity
ERIE logoERIEErie Indemnity CompanyDirect Competitor9.86B213.5620.117.17%13.2%25.03%
KMPR logoKMPRKemper CorporationDirect Competitor1.92B32.7414.303.62%0.83%1.43%0.38
PLMR logoPLMRPalomar Holdings, Inc.Direct Competitor2.94B110.7515.4558.16%22.56%22.79%0.01
HRTG logoHRTGHeritage Insurance Holdings, Inc.Direct Competitor887.78M28.7214.2911.08%17.72%41.44%0.49
HCI logoHCIHCI Group, Inc.Direct Competitor2B154.146.2020.21%33.16%36.22%0.06
PGR logoPGRThe Progressive CorporationProduct Competitor115.34B196.8013.6721.36%12.58%30.23%0.27
ALL logoALLThe Allstate CorporationProduct Competitor56.1B217.925.714.64%18.09%42.74%0.24
TRV logoTRVThe Travelers Companies, Inc.Product Competitor65.22B301.5910.995.17%12.88%19.12%0.28

Compare SAFT vs Peers

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) vs competitors — business, growth, and fundamentals comparison against the closest industry rivals.

Closest Rival

vs ERIE

Most directly comparable listed peer for SAFT.

Scale Benchmark

vs CB

Larger-name benchmark to compare SAFT against a more recognizable public peer.

Peer Set

Compare Top 5

vs ERIE, KMPR, PLMR, HRTG

SAFT Income Statement

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) annual income statement — 10-year revenue, gross profit & net income history

10Y historyFree accessUpdated daily
Line itemDec'17Dec'18Dec'19Dec'20Dec'21Dec'22Dec'23Dec'24Dec'25
Revenue843.66M834.91M875.82M840.4M864.72M785.06M925.95M1.11B1.25B
Revenue Growth %1.97%-1.04%4.9%-4.04%2.89%-9.21%17.95%19.85%13.01%
Medical Costs & Claims503.89M485.51M509.85M404.56M461.73M491.98M642.3M716.64M797.18M
Medical Cost Ratio %59.73%58.15%58.21%48.14%53.4%62.67%69.37%64.58%63.57%
Gross Profit
339.78M▲ 0%
349.39M▲ 2.8%
365.97M▲ 4.7%
435.85M▲ 19.1%
402.99M▼ 7.5%
293.08M▼ 27.3%
283.64M▼ 3.2%
393.1M▲ 38.6%
456.89M▲ 16.2%
Gross Margin %40.27%41.85%41.79%51.86%46.6%37.33%30.63%35.42%36.43%
Gross Profit Growth %1.76%2.83%4.74%19.09%-7.54%-27.27%-3.22%38.59%16.23%
Operating Expenses246.44M239.82M242.29M261.07M238.72M233.5M259.22M303.23M330.21M
OpEx / Revenue %29.21%28.72%27.66%31.07%27.61%29.74%28%27.32%26.33%
Depreciation & Amortization5.04M5.47M5.49M7.53M6.9M6.61M6.95M9.46M0
Combined Ratio %88.94%86.88%85.88%79.2%81%92.41%97.36%91.9%89.9%
Operating Income
93.33M▲ 0%
109.58M▲ 17.4%
123.68M▲ 12.9%
174.77M▲ 41.3%
164.27M▼ 6.0%
59.58M▼ 63.7%
24.42M▼ 59.0%
89.87M▲ 268.0%
126.68M▲ 41.0%
Operating Margin %11.06%13.12%14.12%20.8%19%7.59%2.64%8.1%10.1%
Operating Income Growth %-10.25%17.4%12.87%41.31%-6.01%-63.73%-59.01%268%40.97%
EBITDA98.37M115.04M129.17M182.3M171.17M66.19M31.37M99.33M128.21M
EBITDA Margin %11.66%13.78%14.75%21.69%19.79%8.43%3.39%8.95%10.22%
Interest Expense90K90K90K440K522K524K818K509K1.53M
Non-Operating Income6.54M5.24M-90K-440K-522K-524K-818K-509K-1.53M
Pretax Income
86.7M▲ 0%
104.25M▲ 20.2%
123.68M▲ 18.6%
174.77M▲ 41.3%
164.27M▼ 6.0%
59.58M▼ 63.7%
24.42M▼ 59.0%
89.87M▲ 268.0%
126.68M▲ 41.0%
Pretax Margin %10.28%12.49%14.12%20.8%19%7.59%2.64%8.1%10.1%
Income Tax24.31M21.06M24.08M36.56M33.56M13.02M5.54M19.13M27.43M
Effective Tax Rate %28.04%20.2%19.47%20.92%20.43%21.85%22.71%21.29%21.65%
Net Income
62.39M▲ 0%
83.19M▲ 33.4%
99.6M▲ 19.7%
138.21M▲ 38.8%
130.71M▼ 5.4%
46.56M▼ 64.4%
18.88M▼ 59.5%
70.73M▲ 274.7%
99.25M▲ 40.3%
Net Margin %7.39%9.96%11.37%16.45%15.12%5.93%2.04%6.37%7.91%
Net Income Growth %-3.4%33.35%19.72%38.76%-5.43%-64.38%-59.46%274.75%40.32%
EPS (Diluted)
4.10▲ 0%
5.46▲ 33.2%
6.46▲ 18.3%
9.18▲ 42.1%
8.80▼ 4.1%
3.15▼ 64.2%
1.28▼ 59.4%
4.78▲ 273.4%
6.70▲ 40.2%
EPS Growth %-3.98%33.17%18.32%42.11%-4.14%-64.2%-59.37%273.44%40.17%
EPS (Basic)4.135.526.529.258.853.171.284.796.72
Diluted Shares Outstanding15.14M15.23M15.34M15.12M14.93M14.71M14.71M14.72M14.75M

SAFT Balance Sheet

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) balance sheet — assets, liabilities & shareholders' equity

Line itemDec'17Dec'18Dec'19Dec'20Dec'21Dec'22Dec'23Dec'24Dec'25
Total Assets1.81B1.86B2.02B2.05B2.12B1.97B2.09B2.27B2.47B
Asset Growth %2.79%2.71%8.97%1.56%3.07%-6.84%6.16%8.41%8.86%
Total Investment Assets1.31B1.33B1.47B1.54B2.7B2.34B1.59B1.52B1.69B
Long-Term Investments1.28B1.31B1.44B1.49B1.48B1.29B1.56B1.36B991.69M
Short-Term Investments1.17B1.16B1.23B1.26B1.22B1.05B31.05M553.39M700.02M
Total Current Assets232.36M227.64M001.57B1.62B38.15M0394.09M
Cash & Equivalents41.71M37.58M44.41M53.77M63.6M25.3M38.15M58.97M73.9M
Receivables190.65M190.06M329.85M300.48M290.62M299.8M383.19M464.21M320.19M
Other Current Assets00-1.64B-1.63B274.77M203.14M-566.87M-1.12B-739.7M
Goodwill & Intangibles-2.92M-8.75M001.5B24.95M24.64M24.82M23.88M
Goodwill-75.12M-82.1M001.42B17.09M17.09M17.09M17.09M
Intangible Assets72.2M73.36M0073.02M7.86M7.55M7.73M6.78M
PP&E (Net)9.87M15.58M54.01M53.11M27.11M23.34M31.48M20.27M11.86M
Other Assets-1.03B-1.03B-1.49B-1.55B-1.51B-1.29B400.35M-1.41B-995.81M
Total Liabilities1.11B1.14B1.21B1.17B1.19B1.16B1.29B1.44B1.58B
Total Debt0034M61M57.12M58.34M49.76M45.73M61.86M
Net Debt-41.71M-37.58M-10.41M7.23M-6.49M33.04M11.6M-13.24M-12.04M
Long-Term Debt000030M35M30M061.86M
Short-Term Debt00030M4.74M4.52M4.6M30M11.86M
Total Current Liabilities63.62M80.64M00115.79M25.07M499.73M015.76M
Accounts Payable74.5M84.12M87.93M87.72M85.79M85.32M80.18M96.35M95.64M
Deferred Revenue00000000615.13M
Other Current Liabilities-78.69M-95.36M-94.3M-124.87M25.26M-67.86M414.96M-134.31M-711.62M
Deferred Taxes1000K1000K1000K1000K1000K1000K1000K00
Other Liabilities1.1B0-39.72M-48.61M01.13B586.75M-15.73M1.31B
Total Equity
701.02M▲ 0%
718.64M▲ 2.5%
808.41M▲ 12.5%
884.68M▲ 9.4%
927.17M▲ 4.8%
812M▼ 12.4%
804.27M▼ 1.0%
828.46M▲ 3.0%
892.31M▲ 7.7%
Equity Growth %4.52%2.51%12.49%9.44%4.8%-12.42%-0.95%3.01%7.71%
Shareholders Equity701.02M718.64M808.41M884.68M927.17M812M804.27M828.46M892.31M
Minority Interest000000000
Retained Earnings570.69M616.72M661.55M745.03M821.74M815.31M781.19M798.76M844.06M
Common Stock175K176K177K178K178K179K179K180K181K
Accumulated OCI24.27M-10.71M28.19M53.53M24.58M-80.54M-53.19M-51.05M-17.13M
Return on Equity (ROE)9.1%11.72%13.04%16.33%14.43%5.35%2.34%8.66%11.54%
Return on Assets (ROA)3.5%4.54%5.14%6.78%6.27%2.28%0.93%3.24%4.19%
Equity / Assets38.79%38.72%39.97%43.07%43.79%41.16%38.41%36.49%36.11%
Debt / Equity--0.04x0.07x0.06x0.07x0.06x0.06x0.07x
Book Value per Share46.3247.1952.7158.5162.1255.2054.6756.2960.52
Tangible BV per Share46.5147.7652.7158.51-38.0553.5053.0054.6158.90

SAFT Cash Flow Statement

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) cash flow — operating, investing & free cash flow history

Line itemDec'17Dec'18Dec'19Dec'20Dec'21Dec'22Dec'23Dec'24Dec'25
Cash from Operations82.04M127.69M112.46M109.46M141.39M44.33M52.11M128.69M194.5M
Operating CF Growth %-16.98%55.64%-11.93%-2.66%29.17%-68.65%17.57%146.94%51.14%
Operating CF / Revenue %9.72%15.29%12.84%13.02%16.35%5.65%5.63%11.6%15.51%
Net Income62.39M83.19M99.6M138.21M130.71M46.56M18.88M70.73M99.25M
Depreciation & Amortization5.04M5.47M5.49M7.53M6.9M6.61M6.95M9.46M-1.57M
Stock-Based Compensation5.17M6.58M6.03M7.46M6.29M5.98M4.33M4.48M4.83M
Deferred Taxes2.08M-5.6M4.76M5.16M5.32M-8.37M1.66M380K-1.93M
Other Non-Cash Items-900K17.95M-19.52M-5.74M-41.04M28.49M-13.24M-18.55M-9.99M
Working Capital Changes8.27M20.1M16.11M-43.15M33.21M-34.94M33.55M62.17M103.9M
Cash from Investing-14.92M-83M-52.96M-35.52M-65.99M-19.99M24.27M-54.54M-125.71M
Capital Expenditures-5.96M-11.18M-9.59M-9.95M-8.22M-2.09M-1.78M-4.37M-2.51M
Acquisitions-18.47M4.99M14.78M-23.75M-1.53M-17.59M-2.11M-2.06M0
Purchase of Investments-240.16M-378.13M-263.25M-278.9M-447.67M-287.49M-161.59M-356.74M-122.07M
Sale/Maturity of Investments231.19M306.31M219.88M253.33M389.91M287.18M189.75M308.63M20M
Other Investing18.47M-4.99M-14.78M23.75M1.53M000-21.12M
Cash from Financing-45.46M-48.81M-52.67M-64.57M-65.57M-62.64M-63.53M-53.33M-53.87M
Dividends Paid-45.46M-48.81M-52.67M-54.58M-54.01M-53.04M-53.29M-53.33M-53.87M
Share Repurchases000-40M-11.56M-14.6M-5.24M0-20M
Stock Issued000000000
Debt Issuance (Net)0001000K01000K-1000K01000K
Other Financing000000000
Net Change in Cash
21.66M▲ 0%
-4.13M▼ 119.1%
6.83M▲ 265.4%
9.36M▲ 37.2%
9.83M▲ 5.0%
-38.3M▼ 489.5%
12.85M▲ 133.6%
20.82M▲ 62.0%
14.93M▼ 28.3%
Exchange Rate Effect000000000
Cash at Beginning20.05M41.71M37.58M44.41M53.77M63.6M25.3M38.15M58.97M
Cash at End41.71M37.58M44.41M53.77M63.6M25.3M38.15M58.97M73.9M
Free Cash Flow
76.08M▲ 0%
116.51M▲ 53.1%
102.86M▼ 11.7%
99.51M▼ 3.3%
133.17M▲ 33.8%
42.23M▼ 68.3%
50.33M▲ 19.2%
124.32M▲ 147.0%
191.99M▲ 54.4%
FCF Growth %-18.99%53.13%-11.71%-3.25%33.82%-68.29%19.17%147.01%54.43%
FCF Margin %9.02%13.95%11.74%11.84%15.4%5.38%5.44%11.2%15.31%
FCF per Share5.037.656.716.588.922.873.428.4513.02

SAFT Key Ratios

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) financial ratios — P/E, ROE, debt and 30+ core market and balance-sheet ratios

Metric2016201720182019202020212022202320242025
Combined Ratio87.43%88.94%86.88%85.88%79.2%81%92.41%97.36%91.9%89.9%
Medical Cost Ratio59.64%59.73%58.15%58.21%48.14%53.4%62.67%69.37%64.58%63.57%
Return on Equity (ROE)9.82%9.1%11.72%13.04%16.33%14.43%5.35%2.34%8.66%11.54%
Return on Assets (ROA)3.73%3.5%4.54%5.14%6.78%6.27%2.28%0.93%3.24%4.19%
Equity / Assets38.15%38.79%38.72%39.97%43.07%43.79%41.16%38.41%36.49%36.11%
Book Value / Share44.6246.3247.1952.7158.5162.1255.254.6756.2960.52
Debt / Equity---0.04x0.07x0.06x0.07x0.06x0.06x0.07x
Revenue Growth2.96%1.97%-1.04%4.9%-4.04%2.89%-9.21%17.95%19.85%13.01%

SAFT SEC Filings & Documents

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) SEC filings — annual & quarterly reports (10-K, 10-Q)

8-K Announcements

6
Material company update

May 6, 2026·SEC

Material company update

Feb 25, 2026·SEC

Material company update

Nov 3, 2025·SEC

10-K Annual Reports

4
FY 2026

Feb 27, 2026·SEC

FY 2025

Feb 27, 2025·SEC

FY 2024

Feb 28, 2024·SEC

10-Q Quarterly Reports

6
FY 2025

Nov 7, 2025·SEC

FY 2025

Aug 8, 2025·SEC

FY 2025

May 9, 2025·SEC

SAFT Frequently Asked Questions

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) stock FAQ — growth, dividends, profitability & financials explained

Growth & Financials

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) grew revenue by 13.0% over the past year. This is steady growth.

Yes, Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) is profitable, generating $99.3M in net income for fiscal year 2025 (7.9% net margin).

Dividend & Returns

Yes, Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) pays a dividend with a yield of 4.92%. This makes it attractive for income-focused investors.

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) has a return on equity (ROE) of 11.5%. This is reasonable for most industries.

Industry Metrics

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) has a combined ratio of 89.9%. A ratio below 100% indicates underwriting profitability.

Explore More SAFT

Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT) financial analysis — history, returns, DCA and operating performance tools

Total Return Calculator

Historical returns with dividends reinvested

→

DCA Calculator

Dollar cost averaging vs lump sum

→

Dividend History

Yield, growth, payout safety & DRIP

→

Earnings History

EPS trends, net income & profitability

→

Price History

Long-term charts & historical price data

→

Revenue History

Sales growth patterns & revenue breakdown

→

Financial Ratios

30 years of market, efficiency and balance-sheet ratios

→

Valuation

DCF intrinsic value, peer multiples & estimates

→
VCP ScannerFree US Stock Screener & Financial Analysis

Find stocks. Verify deeply. Act with conviction.

Patterns find ideas. Fundamentals build conviction.

Data updated daily

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Screener
  • Themes
  • Market Valuation
  • Valuation
  • Compare
  • Total Return
  • DCA Calculator
  • News
  • Insights
  • Methodology
  • How It Works
  • Profile

Popular Screens

  • VCP Hot
  • VCP Warm
  • Value Screens
  • Growth Screens
  • Momentum Screens
  • Technical Screens
  • Quality Screens

Community

  • Follow @VCPScanner on X

Get weekly stock ideas — free

© 2026 VCP Scanner. All rights reserved.
About·Privacy Policy·Terms of Service
Not financial advice. Do your own research.