VCP Scanner
Stock Screener
Filter stocks with fundamental & technical criteria
Market Themes
Curated industry baskets & thematic leaders
Earnings Hub
Calendar, EPS surprise stats & earnings transcripts
Market News
Real-time market intelligence & AI overviews
Insider Buying
SEC Form 4 corporate insider purchases
LearnAll lessons
Candlestick Patterns44 candles, each on two real charts
Pattern GuidesThe playbooks' setups on real breakouts
GlossaryInvesting terms in plain English
MinerviniVCP SetupsTrend Template
O'NeilCup with HandleFlat BaseDouble BottomCANSLIM Leaders
QullamaggieHigh Tight FlagsFlag BreakoutsEpisodic PivotsMomentum Leaders
KellWedge PopEMA Crossback
LivermorePivotal Points
PatternsFalling Wedge & ChannelBase Breakouts
View All Playbooks...
BreakoutsScanner
FAANG & Tech
AAPL vs MSFTNVDA vs AMDGOOGL vs META
Cloud & Cyber
CRM vs NOWCRWD vs PANWSNOW vs DDOG
Consumer & Auto
TSLA vs FAMZN vs WMTNFLX vs DIS
Finance & Crypto
JPM vs BACV vs MACOIN vs MSTR
Index & ETFs
SPY vs QQQVTI vs VOOSPY vs IWM
Compare Any Stocks...
DCF ValuationCalculate intrinsic value of US stocks
Market ValuationBuffett indicator, CAPE & macro gauges
Total ReturnSee dividends + price return history
DCA CalculatorSimulate recurring buys & compounding
VisualizeInteractive multi-year financial charts
Watchlist
BreakoutsScanner
WatchlistPricing
Ctrl K
Pricing
SIGI
← Back to Screener
VCP ScannerFree US Stock Screener & Financial Analysis

Find stocks. Analyze deeply. Research with clarity.

Data updated daily

Product

  • Screener
  • Scanner
  • Themes
  • Valuation
  • Total Return
  • DCA Calculator
  • Pricing
  • News
  • Earnings

Resources

  • Market Valuation
  • Compare
  • Insider Activity
  • Methodology
  • How It Works
  • Glossary
  • Learn

Get Ideas

Get weekly market insights — free

© 2026 VCP Scanner
AboutPrivacyTermsRefund Policy
Not financial advice. Do your own research.
ScreenerBreakoutsScannerWatchlist
SIGISelective Insurance Group, Inc.
$103.78$6.1B
Overview & Tools
OverviewChart Terminal ↗Visualize
Valuation & Forecasts
Valuation ModelsEstimatesDCF Model
Price & Analyst Data
Analyst TargetsPrice History
Financial Statements
Income StatementBalance SheetCash FlowRatios & Margins
Performance
P/E HistoryRevenue HistoryEarnings HistoryDividend HistoryTotal Return
Discovery & Screens
Live BreakoutsStock ScreenerOwnership
  1. Home
  2. Financial Ratios

  1. Home
  2. Stocks
  3. SIGI
  4. Financial Ratios

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) Financial Ratios

Latest Ratios: P/E Ratio 12.0x · EV/EBITDA 10.7x · ROE 13.9%. (1996–2025 historical series)

Income StatementBalance SheetCash FlowRatios
AnnualQuarterly

SIGI Valuation Multiples

Price-based multiples — how expensive the stock is relative to earnings, sales, book value, and cash flow

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Market Cap$6.1B$5.1B$5.7B$6.1B$5.4B$5.0B$4.0B$3.9B$3.6B$3.5B$2.5B
Enterprise Value$7.1B$6.1B$6.2B$6.6B$5.9B$5.5B$4.6B$4.5B$4.1B$3.9B$2.9B
P/E Ratio →12.0211.1928.9517.0325.0312.6116.3814.3920.3120.6715.94
P/S Ratio1.130.961.181.431.521.471.381.371.411.411.11
P/B Ratio1.741.421.842.052.131.671.471.782.032.031.65
P/FCF5.374.285.368.246.956.637.598.768.299.538.12
P/OCF4.964.155.217.996.726.447.298.198.009.187.68

P/E links to full P/E history page with 30-year chart

SIGI EV Ratios

Enterprise-value multiples — capital-structure-neutral measures of total business value

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
EV / Revenue—1.141.281.561.661.621.581.571.571.571.28
EV / EBITDA10.669.8121.2613.5118.359.7612.7411.4415.8012.3410.37
EV / EBIT12.059.5521.7013.5519.1510.2313.8312.1117.1713.5412.04
EV / FCF—5.115.828.967.627.308.6810.049.2410.619.38

SIGI Profitability

Margins and return-on-capital ratios measuring operating efficiency

Margins

Full margin charts and quarterly trend are on the Earnings History page

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Gross Margin40.9%40.9%6.6%12.2%9.6%16.7%12.3%14.1%10.1%13.1%12.2%
Operating Margin11.0%11.0%5.3%10.8%7.9%15.0%10.4%11.8%8.2%10.6%9.6%
Net Profit Margin8.7%8.7%4.3%8.6%6.3%12.0%8.4%9.5%6.9%6.8%6.9%

Return on Capital

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
ROE13.9%13.9%6.8%13.3%8.2%14.1%10.0%13.6%10.2%10.4%10.8%
ROA3.5%3.5%1.8%3.5%2.3%4.3%2.9%3.5%2.5%2.5%2.4%
ROIC10.8%10.8%5.5%10.5%6.4%11.2%7.5%10.1%7.4%9.8%8.9%
ROCE5.5%5.5%2.7%5.4%3.4%6.4%4.2%5.3%3.6%4.6%4.1%

SIGI Leverage & Debt

Solvency and debt-coverage ratios — lower is generally safer

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Debt / Equity0.280.280.180.190.220.180.220.260.240.260.28
Debt / EBITDA1.621.621.901.121.700.971.631.481.681.391.53
Net Debt / Equity—0.270.160.180.210.170.210.260.230.230.26
Net Debt / EBITDA1.591.591.681.091.620.891.591.461.621.251.39
Debt / FCF—0.830.460.730.670.671.081.280.951.071.26
Interest Coverage12.9512.959.9416.9210.7118.3310.8210.999.6711.7610.66

SIGI Liquidity & Efficiency

Short-term solvency ratios and asset-utilisation metrics

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Current Ratio0.620.620.640.620.610.610.570.590.590.630.61
Quick Ratio0.620.620.640.620.610.610.570.590.590.630.61
Cash Ratio0.010.010.030.010.010.030.010.010.010.040.03
Asset Turnover—0.380.390.380.360.340.320.350.350.350.34
Inventory Turnover———————————
Days Sales Outstanding———————————

SIGI Shareholder Yields

Earnings, FCF, buyback, and dividend yields — total returns to shareholders

Dividends

Full dividend history and growth charts are on the Dividend History page

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Dividend Yield1.5%1.8%1.5%1.2%1.2%1.2%1.3%1.2%1.2%1.1%1.3%
Payout Ratio19.9%19.9%41.0%20.2%29.8%14.9%22.1%17.6%23.5%21.9%21.3%

Total Shareholder Return Metrics

MetricTTMFY 2025FY 2024FY 2023FY 2022FY 2021FY 2020FY 2019FY 2018FY 2017FY 2016
Earnings Yield8.3%8.9%3.5%5.9%4.0%7.9%6.1%6.9%4.9%4.8%6.3%
FCF Yield18.6%23.4%18.6%12.1%14.4%15.1%13.2%11.4%12.1%10.5%12.3%
Buyback Yield1.5%1.8%0.3%0.1%0.3%0.2%0.2%0.2%0.2%0.2%0.2%
Total Shareholder Yield3.0%3.6%1.8%1.3%1.6%1.4%1.5%1.4%1.3%1.2%1.5%
Shares Outstanding—$61M$61M$61M$61M$61M$60M$60M$60M$59M$59M

Key Metrics

Growth RegimeDecelerating
ProfitabilityStrong
Balance SheetAdequate
Cash FlowStable
Top Statement Risk

Social inflation reserve adequacy

Verified Source

Metrics are mathematically derived from official filings.

SEC 10-K (2026Q3)

Combined Ratio Hits Cycle Best Amid Pricing Roll-Off

According to Selective's quarterly ratio record, the combined ratio improved from 106.7% in 2024Q2 to 86.8% in 2026Q3, its strongest level across the ten-quarter series, implying attritional underwriting is now generating meaningful profit rather than merely absorbing catastrophe and loss costs.

The roughly 20-point swing in the combined ratio marks a genuine underwriting inflection, with the 2026Q3 loss ratio of 57.5% and expense ratio of 29.3% producing a 13.2% underwriting margin. However, the data series shifts presentation conventions around 2025Q4 — earlier quarters show expense ratios near 1–2% and loss ratios near 88–105% — which suggests the recent loss/expense split may not be directly comparable to the older readings, and the durability of the 86.8% figure should be assessed on a consistently defined basis. Investors should monitor whether renewal premium change continues to outrun loss trend as hard-market rate gains roll off, since a combined ratio at this level leaves limited room for adverse development.

ROE Rebuilt on Underwriting, Not Just Float

Based on Selective's ten-quarter record, quarterly ROE recovered from -2.1% in 2024Q2 to 3.6% in 2026Q3, annualizing toward the roughly 13.9% return on equity cited in recent company commentary, a recovery that appears driven primarily by the underwriting swing rather than investment yield alone.

With a debt-to-equity ratio near 0.26 and interest coverage around 13x, financial leverage contributes little to the return stack, so the ROE is effectively the sum of underwriting margin plus investment income on float — and the 2026Q3 underwriting margin of 13.2% is doing most of the work. That composition is higher quality than ROEs engineered through leverage, but it also means earnings are more sensitive to any reversal in the combined ratio. Compared to peer ROEs such as Cincinnati's 20.9% or Erie's 24.5%, SIGI's return profile appears mid-tier, which may reflect its more conservative reserving posture rather than inferior franchise economics.

Conservative Leverage Leaves Room to Absorb Shocks

As reported in SIGI's quarterly filings, the debt-to-equity ratio has held between 0.16 and 0.28 across ten quarters, ending at 0.26 in 2026Q3, an intentionally thin financial leverage posture that appears designed to let underwriting cycle volatility play out without threatening the capital base.

The low D/E and 13x interest coverage suggest the capital structure is not the binding constraint on risk-taking; rather, the constraint appears to be surplus growth relative to premium volume. Prior balance sheet work shows liabilities expanding roughly 41% since 2024Q2 while equity grew about 17%, a divergence that means premium-to-surplus may be drifting upward even without explicit leverage decisions. Given that rating agency guidelines typically scrutinize this ratio in the 2–3x range for standard P&C writers, investors should verify whether premium growth outpacing surplus accumulation is tightening that buffer faster than the headline D/E suggests.

P/B Premium Hinges on Earnings Durability

At a price-to-book multiple of 1.64 against a 12.92 trailing P/E, SIGI's current valuation appears to embed mid-teens ROE expectations, a level only modestly below peers such as Cincinnati Financial at 1.75x book, suggesting the market credits underwriting consistency without paying full super-regional franchise multiples.

A 1.64x P/B for an insurer earning roughly 13–14% ROE implies the market expects that return to persist, which is a reasonable but not generous assumption given that current combined ratios sit near cycle bests. The 1.01 PEG and 11.76 forward P/E indicate the market is not pricing aggressive growth — consistent with the decelerating revenue trend noted in SIGI's income statement analysis — so the multiple appears to reflect stable rather than accelerating earnings power. If the combined ratio reverts toward the mid-90s as pricing normalizes, the P/B premium could compress unless float income offsets the underwriting giveback.

Mid-Pack Valuation vs Agency-Focused Comp Set

Relative to the peer table, SIGI's 13.9% ROE and 1.64x book value sit between Cincinnati Financial's 20.9% and 1.75x and Donegal Group's 11.0% and 0.92x, positioning Selective as a middle-of-the-spectrum super-regional whose underwriting quality is recognized but not fully re-rated.

SIGI's valuation discount to Cincinnati is difficult to justify purely on franchise grounds if both operate agency-centric models, though CINF's materially higher ROE and larger investment portfolio may warrant the gap. Meanwhile, the premium to Donegal appears justified by SIGI's superior combined ratio trajectory and larger absolute scale. Specialty-oriented peers such as Palomar (21.6% ROE, 4.13x book) and HCI (28.7% ROE) trade at far richer multiples because their growth and pricing cycles differ structurally, so SIGI's E&S expansion should be evaluated against those comps selectively rather than as a wholesale re-rating catalyst.

Combined Ratio May Overstate Underwriting Quality

The headline 86.7–86.8% combined ratio is the ratio most commonly misapplied to SIGI, because it likely embeds favorable prior-year reserve development that inflates current-period underwriting margin precisely as top-line pricing momentum decelerates, obscuring the true attritional loss trend.

A loss ratio moving from roughly 88–105% in earlier quarters to 57.5% in 2026Q3, alongside an expense ratio that simultaneously jumps from ~1–2% to ~29%, suggests a definitional shift in the data that makes period-over-period comparison unreliable and could mask adverse development in casualty lines flagged as a persistent social inflation risk. The better analytical tool is the ex-catastrophe, constant-claim-definition attritional loss ratio, triangulated with prior-year development disclosures, since the cash flow record's extreme OCF/NI ratios (as high as 4.20) and periodic zero-claims quarters indicate reserve payment timing that complicates reading earnings quality from any single period. Investors should treat the current combined ratio as a floor-case representation rather than a sustainable run-rate until reserve adequacy is confirmed against rising litigation costs.

Download Financial Ratios Data

Includes 30+ ratios · 30 years · Updated daily

Consensus & Technical Research Suite
Open SIGI Terminal

SIGI Chart Terminal

WASM

Live VCP patterns, Cup & Handle overlays, support/resistance, and AI trade plans.

Launch Terminal

Live Breakouts Feed

LIVE

High-probability breakout stocks crossing their pivot across 5 pattern engines.

Explore Setups

Intrinsic Valuation

DCF models, multiple analysis, and analyst estimates.

Check Valuation

Historical Returns

10-year return with dividends reinvested.

Calculate

Peer Comparison

Compare growth, multiples, and margins vs sector.

Compare

SIGI — Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers to the most common questions about buying SIGI stock.

What is Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s P/E ratio?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s current P/E ratio is 12.0x. The historical average is 17.3x. This places it at the 37th percentile of its historical range.

What is Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s EV/EBITDA?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s current EV/EBITDA is 10.7x. This enterprise value multiple compares the company's total value (equity + debt - cash) to its EBITDA. The historical average is 12.2x.

What is Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s ROE?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s return on equity (ROE) is 13.9%. The historical average is 9.9%.

Is SIGI stock overvalued?

Based on historical data, Selective Insurance Group, Inc. is trading at a P/E of 12.0x. This is at the 37th percentile of its historical P/E range. Compare with industry peers and growth rates for a complete picture.

What is Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s dividend yield?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s current dividend yield is 1.48% with a payout ratio of 19.9%.

What are Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s profit margins?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. has 40.9% gross margin and 11.0% operating margin. Operating margin between 10-20% is typical for established companies.

How much debt does Selective Insurance Group, Inc. have?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc.'s Debt/EBITDA ratio is 1.6x, indicating moderate leverage. A ratio below 2x is generally considered financially healthy.